Monday Ministerial Musings
By Rev. Mark William Ennis
2023 Blog #48
December 4, 2023
The Brooklyn Archdiocese Suspended a Priest for What?
I recently read in the New York Times that there was discipline done to a priest, Monsignor Jamie J. Gigantiello. The diocese of Brooklyn removed him from his administrative duties because he allowed a music video to be filmed in his congregation, Our Lady of Mount Carmel-Annunciation of the Blessed Virgin Mary, in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. He was disciplined just a few days after his “crime” was seen publicly.
What was his crime? He allowed a pop singer, Sabrina Carpenter, to film a music video inside the sanctuary. Part of the music video shows coffins on the altar of the church as Sabrina dances and sings. Apparently, the church hierarchy was offended by her song or having coffins on the altar. I watched the video and didn’t see anything to be offended about. You may watch it here if you like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kLbn61Z4LDI
What amazed me was the rapid response in relieving the Monsignor of his duties. For two decades now I have been counseling victims of religious abuse. A number of these victims were sexually abused by priests. Most recently I have worked with a group “My Sanctuary Healing,” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HWVzWYqGKvU&list=PLTOsN58Bh3VXkYo8S-22DS9ATTllz1-P6
I have found a pattern amid such abuse victims: they all report the slow response of the church to discipline priests who have perpetrated sexual abuse. Often, instead of discipline, these perpetrators are moved, parish to parish to be given “another chance.” Of course, such perpetrators commit other crimes against innocent people.
The feature film, “Spotlight,” chronicles how a few priests perpetrated sexual crimes for decades and never received the same discipline that Monsignor Gigantiello received. One must wonder why he received harsher discipline than priests who are, or have been, sexual predators. One only has to do a web search to see how many priests in Brooklyn alone were sexual predators but were not disciplined for years or decades. What makes this music video so offensive that a Monsignor had to be disciplined over it? Is allowing a music video, which was offensive to some, more offensive than sexual offenses against children? Such offenses against children ought to enrage all of us. I believe that I can safely say that God is enraged over children being hurt.
When the church disciplines a priest for allowing a music video to be filmed in church, faster than it reacts to child sexual abuse, the church, I believe, is not listening to Jesus. I am reminded of the book published by Jimmy Breslin several years ago entitled, “The Church that forgot Christ.” Protecting children and adults from abuse must be a higher priority than being concerned about a music video that offended some but not others.
According to the media, this music video by Sabrina Carpenter was viewed 9.7 million times on You Tube. The diocese of Brooklyn ought to congratulate Monsignor Gigantiello for finding a way to get 9.7 million people to see the inside of the church. Perhaps the church should make some music videos to attract a wider audience but above all, the church must keep abuse from happening and swiftly prosecute those who hurt others.
#ReformedChurchInAmerica #PastorMarkAuthor.com
#BergenCounty #BergenfieldNJ
#MonsignorGigantiello #SabrinaCarpenter
#BrooklynDiocese #ProtectingChildren
To read more of Pastor Mark’s writings, please look at his website:
Pastor Mark Author 